Early Intervention - Identification - High School
Scenario | Introduction | Strategies | Barriers | Resources | Comments | Key Words
Jeffrey is in trouble. When he first entered the large high school he was feeling nervous. He was a special education student with a communication disorder and a secret. Jeffrey could not read. School was challenging but Jeffrey had been successful due to the individualized attention provided by his teachers. Jeffrey had been in and out of foster homes since age 10. He never asked for help with homework. However, his foster mother had recently reported that she was worried about Jeffrey, because he was losing interest in school and was starting to hang out with a group of boys involved in gangs.
Over the summer, Jeffrey began to get in trouble in his neighborhood to gain status with his new friends. When he returned to school in the fall, he was sent to the office for sleeping in class, throwing paper at the teacher, and got in a fight. Everyone seemed surprised by the change in Jeffrey’s demeanor. These risk taking behaviors just started when he entered high school and began hanging out with a different crowd. Jeffrey reported that he did not want to go to school. He said that it was too hard and he was failing some of his classes. He informed the counselor the he intended to dropout of school as soon as he turned sixteen.
Some may ask, “Why is it so important to identify those students at risk for dropping out of school?” The answer is far reaching. It affects the student, the community and society at large. When a student drops out it costs everyone something. Each year’s class of dropouts will cost the country over 200 billion dollars in lost earnings and unrealized tax revenue. Nearly 1/2 of the heads of households on welfare and an even greater percentage of the prison population, are comprised of those who have dropped out of school. The average annual cost of maintaining a prisoner is at least 3 times higher than the annual dollars expended to educate a school age child (Hale, 1998).
These statistics do not even consider the human cost to the dropouts and society. Poor self-esteem, few career possibilities, and a feeling of hopelessness can not be measured by any monetary figure. Society and schools can not afford to allow a single child to leave school early. The No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 proposed to close the achievement gap using accountability, flexibility, and choice. In addition, this Act focuses upon states developing dropout prevention strategies and implementing them successfully.
Kentucky has also adopted such a policy. Kentucky’s current dropout rate as reported in Kentucky Education Facts, 2002 is 4.79% for 2000-2001. To address this dropout rate, the Kentucky legislature has proposed the following goals to be achieved by 2006:
Communities and schools must learn how to identify those students who are at risk for leaving school. The identification of situations and behaviors that place students at an increased risk for dropping out will enable and empower communities, educators, and parents to reach these students and provide a system of support that they so vitally need. As President Bush said," When it comes to the education of our children…failure is not an option” (Bush, 2001).
Educators who can develop the tools necessary to recognize the behaviors and situations associated with students who drop out, and provide early intervention for the at-risk high school student can help each child find success in academics and in life itself. Teachers and administrators must be able to recognize the risk factors and situations that motivate students to leave school. They must be able to correctly identify characteristics of the risk factors such as absenteeism, retention, lack of connection and socio-economic situations so that early intervention is possible.
CHARACTERISTICS and IDENTIFICATION INDICATORS
While there is no one factor that can be identified as the sole reason for students dropping out in middle school and high school, there are several factors that, when combined, can lead to students leaving school. The following characteristics provide a list of general behaviors and factors associated with dropout and include a web link(s) for in-depth discussion of these characteristic(s):
ABSENTEEISM
Absenteeism is often considered to be one of the strongest predictors during middle school years that a student is at-risk for dropping out of school in the future. It was found to be the strongest predictor of dropping out in an analysis of the High School and Beyond database (Bryk & Thum, 1989). Roderick (1993) found that there are variables that separate high school dropouts from lower achieving students who graduated. One of these variables was a significant drop in attendance during the middle school years (10+ days annual increase over elementary attendance). During the same time, lower achieving students who graduated averaged not more than five days of absences (Tompkins & Deloney, 1994).
The amount of time actually spent in the classroom is in direct correlation to a student’s access to education. If students are tardy, absent, or cut class they relinquish their opportunity for an education; they also disrupt classes by being late or absent interfering with other students’ opportunities to learn. The undesirable habit of being consistently late or absent will not serve students well in their future work lives. The U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics', Schools and Staffing Survey (1990-91) statistics in this resource show the results of a teacher questionnaire, demonstrating that absenteeism and tardiness is a serious problem.
Click on STRATEGIES SECTION for discussion of the strategies listed below. School and support staff may choose to implement these suggestions after identifying students who have experienced absenteeism and truancy.
ACADEMIC FAILURE and RETENTION
Academic failure has been sited has a major reason why students drop out of school. Retention, which is often a result of academic failure, is another factor contributing to dropout. According to data from the National Educational Longitudinal Study in 1988, one in five 8th graders had been retained at least once since first grade. These statistics point out a need for early and on-going intervention to bring students up to grade level. Consequently, prevention of academic failure will, in most cases, eliminate the need for retention and social promotion and provide support for students to successfully complete the school experience.
Research has shown, however, that retaining middle school students does not improve academic achievement and may indicate that schools are not helping the at-risk student make up for the deficiencies that began in elementary school (Massachusetts Advocacy Center, 1986). Also, young adolescents are more stigmatized by retention. (Wells, A, 1999).
School and support staff may choose to implement these suggestions after identifying
students who have experienced academic failure or retention.
LACK OF CONNECTION
Students are more likely to become disassociated from school and peers during transitional years. The move from an elementary school to a larger middle school can be overwhelming for some students. Students’ perceptions of the quality of school life decline as they progress from elementary to secondary school, with the largest decline occurring during the transition to a middle level school (Diemert, 1992). The lack of involvement in extracurricular activities has been cited as a possible at-risk identifier; therefore a major consideration should be including programs that focus on meeting social needs of students, as well as academics and regulations.
Click on STRATEGIES SECTION for further discussion of the strategies for teachers to utilize as they identify early signs of a student’s lack of connection to peers or school. These strategies are listed as:
LOW SOCIO-ECONOMIC BACKGROUND
It is getting more difficult to conduct school as we have in the past because more students are coming from poverty. “An education is the key to getting out of, and staying out of generational poverty. Individuals leave poverty for one of four reasons: a goal or vision of something they want to be or have; a situation that is so painful that anything would be better; someone who ”sponsors” them (i.e. an educator, spouse, mentor, or role model who shows them a different way or convinces then that they could live differently); or a special talent or ability that provides an opportunity for them” (Payne, 2001).
Students who come from a lower socio-economic background are more likely to be at risk to drop out than their middle class counter parts. Donnelly (1987) indicated that students who drop out come from low socio-economic families. A possible explanation includes low educational backgrounds of parents and low expectations for the children.
Click on STRATEGIES SECTION for further discussion of the strategies listed below. School and support staff may choose to implement these suggestions after identifying students who come from a low socio-economic background.
See the DOP Resource Guide topics: Transition; Extra-Curricular Activities; Student Support
ETHNIC BACKGROUND
Minorities have been found to be at greater risk for dropping out of school. Language and cultural differences can also create a factor or barrier for these students. The United States Bureau of Census indicates that Hispanics are more likely than other ethnic or cultural groups to drop out of school.
One explanation for the problem of school dropout among minority students is the theory “cultural discontinuity.” This theory centers on the possible mis-match between the culture of another student and the culture of school. Boykin (1962) argues that much of the school failure that African American children experience in school can be explained in terms of cultural discontinuity resulting from a mis-match between salient cultural issues in minorities versus those typically afforded in American schools.
“Cultural competence” is defined as a set of congruent behaviors, attitudes, and policies that come together in a system, agency, or among professionals. Andenables that system, agency, or those professionals to work effectively in cross-cultural situations (Cross et al., 1989).
In Kentucky, the dropout rate for Hispanic students has increased from 6.65 in 2000 to 7.40 in 2001. How recently a student’s family migrated to the United States may contribute to why more Hispanic students are dropping out (Education Statistics Quarterly).
“African American and Hispanic youth are disproportionately represented in the dropout population. Eighty percent of the Hispanic dropouts speak Spanish at home. For those who speak limited English or none at all, the outlook is especially bleak—with dropout rates over 60%" (McMillen, Kaufman & Whitener, 1994, p. 48). Students who are both low income and minority status are at a higher risk for dropping out. For more information, go to the Kentucky Department of Education, Division of Equity website, and the Dropout Prevention Resource Guide topic: Equity.
Click on STRATEGIES SECTION for discussion of ways school and support staff can implement “culturally competent services” and help reduce dropout for at-risk middle school students.
Strategies include:
LACK OF FAMILY INVOLVEMENT
The involvement of parents or family members in the education of their children both at school and in the home is supported in the research as one of the keys to achieving success in schools. Family involvement is associated with higher levels of student performance, improved behavior, and greater parent and community support for schools (Henderson, 1987). These factors play an especially critical role in the social, emotional, physical, and intellectual development of young adolescents. During middle school years students often make critical decisions that affect the quality of their lives. It is estimated that one in every four adolescents are in serious jeopardy because of their vulnerability to the negative consequences of multiple high risk behaviors such as school failure, substance abuse, and sexual involvement. (Carnegie, 1989)
In order to positively impact these issues, it is essential that effective partnerships with families be developed. This requires that all school staff create a welcoming school environment. Families should be encouraged to raise questions and voice their concerns, as well as participate appropriately in decision-making. Developing these partnerships most often requires that school staff provide families with the information and training they need to become involved. And that the schools provide the opportunities for families to be invited to participate in their children’s’ learning.
Family involvement in the schools can neither be seen as a quick fix nor a luxury; it is a fundamental point of a healthy school system (Henderson, 1987). The array of services that schools are expected to provide to meet the needs of students within the classrooms require additional financial and human resources.
Selected strategies for successful programs are categorized using the Loucks and Loucks(1990) model. (Loucks and Waggoner, 1998).
Go to STRATEGIES SECTION for discussion of a few strategies in each of the six categories listed below. A more comprehensive list of strategies can be found in the book entitled: Keys to Re-engaging Families in the Education of Young Adolescents, Loucks & Waggoner, 1998. Comprehensive family involvement programs involve strategies from:
Links for more information: KDE Parents & Families; National PTA, National Network of Partnership Schools, John Hopkins University, Parent Leadership Associates
LACK OF COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT
Involving community members allows for their input and develops a sense of “ownership” that is necessary for all schools to succeed. “Ownership” for at-risk high school students can promote a sense of belonging, and a sense of responsibility toward the school and themselves. Cunningham (2002) reported that public engagement also gives school systems and stakeholders the opportunity to learn about trends among youth and in the community that might influence academic outcomes. The entire community may benefit from understanding social and health conditions that interfere with learning, such as teen pregnancy, inadequate nutrition, and lack of health care. Community involvement can enhance the community’s overall quality of life. Many schools are working with their communities to organize and optimize their resources in ways that place students’ overall well being at the heart of the school program (Tonaka, 1996). These initiatives, called school health programs, are both comprehensive and coordinated (Marx, et al,1998).
In Kentucky, the Family Resource Youth Service Centers (FRYSC) promote identification and coordination of existing resources, in order to remove barriers to educational success for all children and their families. The centers work closely with community resources to ensure that the appropriate services are available to meet the needs of the students and families that have been identified. Often the FRYSC’s are the schools link to all community service providers including government agencies, private organizations, civic clubs, charitable organizations and individuals. This community collaboration is a vital ingredient in making services readily accessible and in leveraging a partnership that can assist and influence the overall educational experience. Throughout the state, communities are engaging with at risk students through implementation of Search Institute’s 40 Developmental Assets. Many Kentucky communities are being designated as a “Community of Promise” through the America’s Promise Initiative.
The Five Promises are:
ABSENTEEISM STRATEGIES
Longitudinal Student Data
Longitudinal student data provides a method to follow students through their school career. This process differs from tracking, focuses on needs of each student, and also provides a better idea of student’s academic and social needs. Dougherty (2001) reported that matching student records longitudinally provides a rich store of data for evaluating the long-term impact of early childhood, bilingual, or dropout prevention programs.
Big Brother/Big Sister In-School Mentoring Program (Todd Co., KY)
Elementary through grade 11, district-wide administrators, current teachers, retired teachers and other school personnel are the first choices as mentors. Other thoroughly screened volunteers from the community may also serve, if needed, in this one hour per week program that has shown much success in Todd County Kentucky Schools. Contact person: Vicki Myers, Director of Pupil Personnel, Todd County Board of Education; 804 South Main Street; Elkton, KY 42220; (270) 265-2436; vmyers@TODD.k12.KY.US.
Truancy Mediation Program (Todd Co, KY)
After five unexcused absences, the student and parent must visit the Todd County Truancy Mediator, a retired social worker, who is an employee of the Todd County Board of Education, whose office is located in the Todd County Courthouse. The student and parent are interviewed to discover the reasons for the attendance problems, refers them to other sources of help, as needed; goes over the district’s attendance policy and has them sign an attendance contract. Contact person: Vicki Myers, Director of Pupil Personnel, Todd County Board of education; 804 South Main Street; Elkton, KY 42220; (270) 265-2436; vmyers@TODD.k12.KY.US.
ACADEMIC FAILURE and RETENTION STRATEGIES
Recognition of Student Improvement (small step celebrations)
Teachers, counselors, administrators and parents need specific strategies to “rescue” students who are on a downward spin to giving up on school. High school students who have failed to achieve academically are probably experiencing significant skill gaps. Academic demands are overwhelming and an opportunity to demonstrate improvement is rare. Following are some practical ideas for helping students improve skills and for rebuilding students’ self-confidence and desire to continue in school.
For example, if the student is below grade level in Reading, find a high interest, low vocabulary book and listen to the student read a short passage. (Your school librarian can help with selecting the appropriate). You may want to try using a Driver’s Manual, since high school students are thinking about learning to drive. Note the problems the student has with printed text. Praise the student for their efforts and assist them in reading a short passage, if needed. Use the information gained to provide materials & instruction.
Talk with the student about setting a goal. Write it down. Guide the student in identifying 2-3 steps (actions/behaviors) that he/she can do to reach the goal. This works best if the student verbalizes the “steps”. Talk periodically with the student about progress toward the goal. The guidance counselor or ESS teacher may be helpful in assisting the student in making personal goals that he/she can realistically achieve. Provide encouragement and support, even for small steps of accomplishment. This is critical for students who have experienced failure in the past.
Example: GOAL: To pass the next science test.
STEPS:
Stop losing the science handouts. Organize them in a notebook. Complete today’s homework assignment. Make vocabulary cards and practice with a friend.
Focus on the Student’s “Individual Graduation Plan” (IGP)
Beginning with the class of 2002, each Kentucky high school student must complete an Individual Graduation plan. The plan may begin in the sixth grade, but no later than eighth grade. The process is designed to get parents and students involved together in planning the students’ academic and career goals. A career choice is not a permanent commitment, thus the IGP is updated annually with parents/guardians and the student’s advisor if revisions are to be made to the plan.
To learn all of the details of the IGP, see the Kentucky Department of Education’s web site.
For additional information on Kentucky schools that have successful programs contact the following:
Madison Southern High School Walton-Verona Ind. (Grades 7-12)
Richmond, KY 40475 Walton, KY 41094
Contact person: Kathy Vocker, Counselor Contact Person: Melissa Wells, Counselor
(859) 624-4500 (859) 485-4181
Henry County High School
New Castle, KY 40050
Contact person: Judy Rice, Teacher
(502) 845-8670
Teach Study Skills
Students sometimes experience failure because they lack the organization and study skills necessary to successfully meet academic demands of the school day. Helpful strategies may include: time management, test preparation, note taking tips, scanning context for key information, mapping, outlining, mnemonics for association, and others.
For information on how to teach these skills and relate them to content areas in the curriculum, contact a program consultant in the KDE Extended School Services Branch at (502) 564-3678.
Build a Relationship with the Student
Give support and praise for small accomplishments and effort. As a classroom teacher, you may not have opportunity to spend personal quality time with an at- risk student. Encourage support from others, i.e. administrators (principal, central office personnel) and/or individuals in the community. These individuals can be mentors for students who are at risk of dropping out of school.
Kentucky programs that have successfully used mentorship programs are:
Refer to “Mentoring” in the KDE Dropout Prevention Resource Guide for ideas on how to set up a mentorship program for at-risk students.
Utilization of Integration - Team Teacher Approach
The message “It takes a whole village to raise a child”, depicts the theory behind integration. Integration activities have encouraged career and technical education and academic teachers to work together to educate the whole child. The connection between academic and career and technical education instruction enable students to make a smooth transition between school and the “real world”.
Programs that integrate academic and career and technical education are among the fastest growing and most promising innovations in secondary education today. According to Dr. Gene Bottoms, Director of the Southern Regional Education Board, “These programs boost academic performance for ALL students because integrated learning is how people train in the real world" (Bottoms, 1997). Teachers are now realizing that through integration activities, they are able to expand their teaching strategies and are able to reach more students.
For examples of activities and units of study, “The Key to Learning” The Integration of Academics and Vocational Education, 1998-99, contact the Kentucky Department of Education, Division of Career and Technical Education, (502) 564-3775
Implementation of a Differentiated Instruction Approach
High school students who have experienced repeated academic failure and/or retention may need a differentiated approach to learning content and acquiring specific skills. The book, Differentiated Instructional Strategies: One Size Doesn’t Fit All, by Gregory, G.H. & Chapman, C., (2002), Corwin Press, Inc., can be ordered at the following address:
E-mail: order@corwinpress.com.
Create a Climate for Learning
Students need to believe they can learn, and that what they are learning is useful, relevant, and meaningful. The brain responds to the entire sensory content in which learning takes place. To create a learning climate, establish the following:
Know the Learner
Create a student profile tool that can give you information about how students learn (learning style preferences/multiple intelligences) as well as personal interests that may motivate students to learn. For example, ask such questions as:
Continue to gather data and observe struggling students to determine their unique ways of learning. Then consciously include a variety of learning experiences.
Deliver Curriculum in a Variety of Ways
Sometimes students become disinterested in school because they are bored; others because they have failed to learn through traditional teaching methods/styles. Curriculum can be delivered in many ways so it will appeal to individual learners and meet the need for engaging activities and meaningful experiences.
For EXAMPLE:
This is a collection of material designed with a purpose and goal in mind. Students work with center materials to develop, discover, create, and learn a task/concept/skill at their own pace.
To set up a learning center:
Engage Students in Projects (with content focus)
Projects can be varied and rich with opportunities for engaging students, capturing their interest in a content area, and extending learning through a fresh approach. When struggling students feel a connection and can make a contribution to activities at school, they are less likely to consider dropping out of school.
Projects in differentiated classrooms generally deal with a particular topic of study, but differ in nature. There are “structured projects,” topic-related projects” and “open-ended projects.” All projects need to be designed with an end in mind, based on clear learning goals, standards, and content objectives.
An example of project based learning is the “Senior Project”. Senior Projects provide students with an opportunity to choose areas that interest them, to conduct in depth research and to demonstrate problem-solving, decision-making and independent learning skills.
For more information on Senior Projects view the Senior Project Guide.
This guide provides step-by-step instructions for making senior projects a key component of a strong senior year characterized by challenging courses and practical experiences for work and further education.
For additional information on Kentucky Schools that have successful senior projects contact the following:
For additional information on project based learning visit the following websites:
Refer Struggling Students to Extended School Services
The purpose of Extended School Services, or ESS, is to provide additional academic support for at-risk students. A major emphasis in recent years has been that of focusing on students whose behaviors and school performance indicate a potential for school dropout.
Every school in Kentucky has in place a referral system that teachers or parents can use to access needed support for struggling students. Following referral, the ESS teacher and regular class teacher work together to identify specific skill needs, establish student goals, provide appropriate materials and instruction, and monitor student progress.
EXAMPLE of an ESS Program:
The name of the school's ESS program is “Second Chance for Success.” It is designed to encourage students to improve their failing grades. The program is scheduled at the end of each six week grading period. To participate in the program, students must regularly attend the before or after school tutoring and complete the work from referring teachers as specified on a learning contract. This contract lists the concepts, skills, and/or assignments which the student must complete and is signed by the student’s parent, the referring teacher, and the student. If the student completes the assigned work that was missed or inadequate, he/she can earn a passing grade for the given period.
Second Chance sessions meet every Tuesday and Thursday. Students may attend both morning and afternoon sessions, if desired. ESS teachers are qualified to provide individual instruction. Transportation is provided.
For more information contact Beth Southworth or Ken Wright, Scott County Schools, (502) 863-3663
ESS is designed to be an aggressive, proactive program, which seeks to diminish academic problems before they become recurring long- term problems for the student. Through planned intervention, the performance gap between participating students and their peers is closed instead of allowed to widen. ESS throughout the state offers a wide array of curricular offerings and instructional formats. High quality ESS programs have been significantly successful in supporting student achievement and preventing school dropout.
For more detailed information on Extended School Services and examples of model programs, contact Jennifer Scarborough at (502) 564-3678. E-mail: jscarbor@kde.state.ky.us.
LACK of CONNECTION STRATEGIES
Develop a Support System for Transition
A well-designed transition plan can make a tremendous difference in the success of high school students and can help ease many of the anxieties and concerns students face as they enter a new environment. Principals, teachers, school counselors, parents, and students at both the middle and high school levels are encouraged to work together in the planning, implementing, and evaluation of annual transition activities. Some suggested activities include the following:
Middle students want to know what high school will be like; also parents want to know and understand high school policies and procedures. Beginning in the spring, before the transition occurs, schools can arrange for student visits to classrooms and for students to become a “member” of a classroom. Older students can serve as guides and mentors; so new students will already have a connection to their new school. In the fall, the high school can plan an ice cream social or picnic for new students, their families, and staff to precede an open house. Student handbooks, which contain important school information, can be distributed to each family.
Providing a support at the high school level for the many transitions adolescents’ face can ease the stress that many at-risk students face on a daily basis. Programs that address this risk factor are: the School Transitional Environment Project (STEP) and Social Decision Making-Social Problem Solving (SDM-SPS). These programs have demonstrated a reduction in the dropout rate of the students and an improved academic performance. View the following web sites for information on these and other programs:
Program Outcomes for Youth by Polk (n.d.)
This web site discusses different programs that have been designed to reach students in middle school and high school who would be considered at-risk for dropping out of school. Selecting a Substance Abuse Prevention Program: A checklist of key elements gives administrators a practical tool to evaluate and compare programs by Elias, Gager, & Leon (1997)
This web site discusses different intervention programs such as Quest, Social Decision-Making, Social Problem Solving, and Drug Resistance programs.For additional information on Kentucky schools that have successful programs contact:
Boone County High School
Florence, KY 41042
School-Within-School for Seniors
Pat Murray, Tech Prep/HSTW Coordinator
(859) 283-1003For more in-depth information on transition see the KDE Dropout Prevention Resource Guide topic: Transition.
The transition years are a time when friendships and social interaction are tremendously important for adolescents. Programs and activities that provide for a social outlet is one way to provide incoming students with an opportunity to get to know other students and to develop positive relationships outside of an academic setting. Several ways to provide social support might include: Big Brother-Big Sister programs with older students as mentors, activity nights for specific grade levels, career and technical education co-curricular clubs such as FBLA or FFA, after school intramurals, band, or school plays.
View the KDE web site for information on grant opportunities and the 21st Century Community Learning Centers (CCLC) program. Also view the KDE Dropout Prevention Resource Guide topics: Mentoring, Extra-Curricular Activities, and Student Support.
Current trends in educational requirements for jobs indicate that 70% of the jobs in the future will require some level of postsecondary education. Therefore, Kentucky must provide increased opportunities for more students to make successful transitions to postsecondary education. All levels of education must collaborate and cooperate in developing articulation agreements that create clear pathways for students to successfully complete transition to the next level without delays, duplications of courses or loss of credit. Articulation builds upon knowledge and skills; bridges the gap between various educational systems; provides maximum utilization of finances, equipment, and personnel; and allows students to exchange credit across educational systems without duplication, without penalty, and without wasting valuable resources.
For additional information on Kentucky schools that have successful programs contact the following:
Walton-Verona Independent High School
Walton, KY
Karen Delaney, Asst. Principal
(859) 485-7721 Pendleton County High School
Falmouth, KY
Helen Shupe or Jody Johnson, Tech Prep Coordinators
(859) 654-3355 For additional information on articulation agreements or Tech Prep Programs contact: Amid Sabie, Department of Career and Technicial Education, (502) 564-4286.
Consider Heterogeneous Grouping
Heterogeneous grouping of at-risk students for cooperative learning can enhance student learning. Cooperative learning is the term used when small groups of students work together collaboratively to complete a task. Students are provided the opportunity to interact with peers of mixed abilities and different backgrounds. These interactions can help develop positive social skills as well as academic success. Additionally, students feel valued while making progress toward academic success. Jones, et al. (1995) reported that diverse groups of students that include different backgrounds, learning styles, and abilities contribute various perspectives and knowledge to challenging tasks. Some suggested strategies for grouping students might include:
Visit the web site: Critical Issue: Providing Effective Schooling for Students at Risk This web site discusses many academic alternatives for the at-risk student. Topics include heterogeneous grouping and benefits, and the changing role of the educator within the classroom. Benefits to students and educators who are teamed together are also discussed.
Utilize Peer Mentoring
Research indicates that students, who are successful academically, in addition to support from parents and teachers, usually have sustained access to other knowledgeable and caring adults (Clarke, 1989). Within the high school system, peer mentoring will promote development of the student’s self-concept and self-esteem. For at-risk students, a peer mentor may help make the difference in whether those students get on the track to success. Some strategies to consider when implementing mentoring programs could include:
See the KDE Dropout Prevention Resource Guide topic: Peer Mentoring
LOW SOCIO-ECONOMIC BACKGROUND STRATEGIES
The following are strategies that Ruby Payne suggested in her book, A Framework for Understanding Poverty. These strategies stress support systems that schools can use to help students that come from a low socio-economic background:
Recent reports on excellence in education recommend that teachers increase the amount of homework they assign and that school administrators establish demanding homework requirements. Many high schools have adopted a homework policy where students are required to have a certain amount of homework every night or several nights a week.
Many poor students do not have access to adults who have the knowledge base to help them with homework. These at-risk students need to participate in an before or after school program designed for extra help. In Kentucky our schools' Extended School Service Program will serve that purpose.
For addition information on developing homework policies visit the following resource: Eddy, Y (1984).
Extended School Services is available in every school in Kentucky for the purpose of providing additional academic instruction for struggling students, grades K-12. A major emphasis in recent years has been to target students whose behavior and school performance indicate potential for school dropout. Students referred to ESS can receive assistance in core content areas, help with study skills, homework, and other areas that have become barriers to academic success. ESS programs are presently offered beyond the school day: before school, after school, evenings, Saturdays, and summer school, based on district needs. There is no cost to the student for these services.
Promoting strong reading and writing skills is an essential component-perhaps the most important component-of any effort to keep at-risk students in school. All of the strategies for dropout prevention must link to, and build on this keystone. Although Reading and Writing may be emphasized more in elementary and middle schools than in high schools, these skills should remain a point of emphasis in secondary schools, particularly for those students at risk of academic failure.
High Schools are emphasizing more reading in ALL courses; such as technical manuals in an automotive or carpentry class. Some schools have initiated a period in each day to stop and read. This reading time maybe for only 10 minutes but everyone including teachers and administrators stop to read.
For more information on Reading and Writing, view the topic in the KDE Dropout Prevention Resource Guide.
Both of these concepts are designed to build longer-term relationships between teachers and students. Students from low socio-economic background often need a secure relationship with a teacher or mentor to provide guidance and direction that they might not get at home.
A school can create and build relationships by providing support systems that demonstrate personal care for struggling students. These supportive individuals promote student achievement, act as role models, and insist upon successful behavior at school (Payne 2001).
View the KDE Dropout Prevention Resource Guide topics: Career Education, Mentoring, Co/Extra Curricula Activities
Many schools have small groups that meet with the counselor, principal, or a teacher during lunch to work on coping strategies. This ongoing group support allows students to discuss issues and ways to deal with those issues. Advisory groups are yet another way to address issues of support. The Family Resource Center within the high school might also offer workshops on coping strategies.
One characteristic of poor communities is that virtually everyone has a VCR because of the value placed on entertainment. A principal in Illinois who had 95% of his parents on welfare started a very successful program of parental education and contact through videos. Each teacher in the building made a 15-minute videotape. During the 15 minutes, the teacher made a personal introduction, gave an overview of the year’s instruction, identified the class expectations, and encouraged the parents to visit or call. Five copies of each video were made and each student could take a copy home and have an adult view the video. This was very successful because parents that were literate could understand, the parent was not dependent on transportation to have a contact with the school, and it prevented unnecessary miscommunication early in the year.
In the beginning, goal setting would focus on what a student wants to accomplish by the end of each day and by the end of the week. Goals should be in writing. At the end of the day, five minutes would need to be taken with the class to see if the goals were met or not. Procedural self-talk would begin in the written form; most students would likely need assistance. This could be done in an adviser/advisee program or individual classes.
By reorganizing the school day and schedule, educators can build support systems into the school day without additional cost.
EQUITY STRATEGIES
These five elements must be manifested in every level of the service delivery
system. They must be reflected in attitudes, structures, policies, and services.
This pedagogy empowers students intellectually, socially, emotionally, and
politically by using cultural referents to impart knowledge skills and attitudes.
(Ladson-Billings, 1994).
- Maintain high standards and expectations for all students.
- Use culturally relevant curriculum materials
- Recognize and incorporate students’ learning styles, cultural
styles, strengths, and native languages.- Link students’ histories and worlds to the subject matter.
- Build teacher-student relationships that are fluid and humanely
equitable.
Obviously, school disruptions cannot be tolerated. But racial and cultural
differences in the definition of good behavior, along with miscommunications
frequently lead to inequitable punishment of students of color by school
personnel who do not respect their style of classroom participation. Further,
arbitrary and excessive consequences for minor offenses can develop in all
students a sense of powerlessness, dependence on authority, and anger that
leads to further misbehavior (Gathercoal, 1998).
Before disciplining students…
- Elicit and consider the reasons for the misbehavior, particularly
as it relates to racial differences between teachers & students.- Respect student concerns
- Seek to uncover information about a problem that the school
might help solve, such as the need for educational supports,
i.e. assistance in securing food and shelter, relief from
victimization through bullying, counseling for trauma,
depression, and family difficulties (Gathercoal, 1998)
For further information on specific strategies, see All Means All: a call to Action: Improving Achievement of African-American Students Across the Commonwealth of Kentucky (October 2000), by The Minority Student Achievement Task Force.
LACK OF FAMILY INVOLVEMENT STRATEGIES
Keys to Reengaging Families in the Education of Young Adolescents, Loucks and Waggoner, 1998, provides a comprehensive list of strategies that addresses the six Parent Involvement categories. The strategies provided below are just a few highlighted in this resource.
Family as Decision Maker and Advocate
Family and School as Communicators
Family as Learners
Family as Teachers/Coaches
Family as Supporters, Volunteers, and Audience
Family, School and Community as Partners
EXAMPLE:
- Television viewing guidelines;
- Ten reasons to read with or to your child
- A monthly calendar or seasonal calendar of things families could be doing together. This could include visiting local sites of interest such as the public library and making something.
- Homework assignments that encourage or even require family and child to discuss, share, or work
- Homework and study procedures
- Homework Hotline;
- A safe walk/ride night for students and family members (possibly in conjunction wit open house). Encourage families to walk or ride to school with their young adolescent and discuss safety rules;
- Frequent opportunities for families to utilize their skills and talents with students by sharing hobbies, life experiences, travels, and career information;
- Problem solving strategies for families: A three-way conference among teacher, family, and child is often more successful. The child has the problem (low grades, poor behavior, etc.) the teacher and the family can collaborate to help find a way to assist the child in resolving the problem.
LACK OF COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT STRATEGIES
America Five Promises and Strategies
Ongoing relationship with caring adults-parents, mentors, tutors or coaches
Community Leaders can assist by bringing together all stakeholders in the community to develop a plan that will facilitate a cadre of adults to support, care, guide, and advocate for all young people especially those most at risk for academic failure.
Safe places with structured activities during non-school hours
Communities can assist in providing safe places with structured activities that address both the physically and emotional needs of the youth especially those middle/high school years.
Healthy start and future
Communities need to work collaboratively with a n array of services and stakeholder to provide the following types of services and opportunities during the entire birth-to 20 age span: economic security, accessible and affordable healthcare, quality health education, adequate nutrition and exercise, safety at home, in school, and in neighborhoods, support system for youth and their parents.
Marketable skills through effective education
Communities can provide support and opportunities that will assist in helping young people make successful transitions from school to work. Providing job shadowing or coop work experience while taking a related class in high school.
Opportunities to give back through community service
Communities can assist schools by providing opportunities and resources though school-based community service or service –learning initiatives. With appropriate training and support there are many different types of service young people can perform in their community with the right support.
Mentoring Programs in KY
Grayson County Schools
Contact person: Debbie Bolton, Instructional Supervisor
(270) 259-4011
Scott County Schools
Contact person: Ken Wright, Instructional Supervisor
(502) 863-3663
Todd County Schools
Big Brother/Big sister In-School Mentoring Program
Elementary through grade 11 district-wide mentoring program.
Contact person: Vicki Myers, Director of Pupil Personnel
Todd County Board of Education, (270) 265-2436, vmyers@todd.k12.ky.us
Williamstown Independent
Contact person: Sally Skinner, District Assessment Coordinator
(859) 824-7144
Other Kentucky Programs
Boone County High School
Transition
Contact Person: Pat Murray
(859) 283-1003
Daviess County High School
Senior Projects
Contact Person: Sue Koett
(270) 684-5285
Extended School Services (ESS)
Kentucky Department of Education
For more information and examples of model programs, contact:
Jennifer Scarborough, Branch Manager
(502) 564-3678
Henry County High School (IGP)
Contact person: Judy Rice
(502) 845-8670
Kentucky Department for Technical Education
Articulation & Tech Prep
Amid Sabie, State Tech Prep Director
(502) 564-4286
Kentucky Family Resource Youth Services Centers (FRYSC)
Promotes, identifies and coordinates resources for children and their families
Contact person: Dr. Sandy Goodlett, Executive Director
Cabinet for Families and Children
(502) 564-4986
Linda Robinson, KDE Liaison
(502) 564-3678
Madison Southern High School
The M.A.P. (Madison Advisory Program) is designed to bring all students, parents and educators together to work on a common academic goal.
Contact person: Kathy Vockery
(859) 986-8424
Marion County High School
Senior Projects
Contact Person: Jane Hogan
(270) 692-6066
Pendleton County High School
Articulation Agreement
Contact Person: Karen DeLaney
(859) 654-3355
South Laurel High School
Senior Projects
Contact Person: Debbie Felts
(606) 862-4727
Walton-Verona Ind
Articulation
Contact Person: Jody Johnson or Helen Shupe
(859) 485-7721
Scott County High School
Extended School Services Program (ESS)
Contact Person: Beth Southworth or Ken Wright
(502) 863-3663
Todd County Schools
Truancy Mediation Program
A truancy mediation program designed for students who accrue five unexcused absences.
Contact person: Vicki Myers, Director of Pupil Personnel
(270) 265-2436
vmyers@todd.k12.ky.us
The above strategies for the identification of at-risk students in high school are most effective when barriers such as diversity acknowledgement, and issues with the community, family and school are addressed. The following are possible barriers to identification.
Ethnic/Language Differences
Language and ethnic differences are not always taken into consideration when a student begins to fail. Too often the assumption of a universal teacher for a universal student precludes the acknowledgement of the language and ethnic differences. (Nadeau, 1997).
Lower Expectations by Educators/ Administrators
Studies indicate that teachers can hold lower expectations for students who are at risk for dropping out. Lowering the standard however does not benefit the child and can actually become a barrier for helping the child find success in school (Equity Center, 1997).
Lower Expectations by Family
Lower parental expectations can increase the possibility of an at-risk student dropping out of school (Dropout Prevention Center/Network).
Bottoms, G.; Cruch, B.; & Johnson, M. (1997). Research brief 9, Academics and vocational teachers working together contribute to higher levels of student achievement. Retrieved January 7, 2003 from the Southern Regional Education Board’s website: from http://www.sreb.org/programs/hstw/publications/briefs/97brief9.asp
Campbell, K. Great Leaps Reading Program
http://www.greatleaps.com
This reading program is research-based and uses proven instructional tactics combined with powerful motivators to remediate a variety of reading problems. It (targets grades K-12 and is efficient in cost and time.
Eddy, Y. (1984). Developing Homework Policies. ERIC Digest (ED256473). Retrieved from http://www.ed.gov/databases/ERIC-Digest/ed256473.html
The Education Alliance (n.d.). Project based learning. What works. Retrieved on January 7, 2003, from the Brown University Website: http://www.breakingranks.org/whatworks/index.shtml
Gregory, G. H. & Chapman, C. (2002). Differentiated instructional strategies: One size doesn’t fit all. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press, Inc.
Hale, L. F. (1998). High school dropouts cost everyone something! School Dropout Prevention: Information and Strategies for Educators. Retrieved August 28, 2002, from National Association of School Psychologist Web site: http://www.naspcenter.org/adol_sdpe.html
This article discusses the major indicators for at risk students. It provides various strategies for parents to use to reengage their child.
Holland, H. (1999). Putting parents in their place. Education Week, 19, 44. Retrieved June 17, 2002, from
http://www.edweek.com/ew/ewstory.cfm?slug=03hollan.h19&keywords=family%20involvement.
The article discusses the need for increased parental involvement within the schools.
Information and research on dropouts and dropout prevention strategies. Washington, DC: Office of Elementary and Secondary Education. Retrieved June 17, 2002, from
http://www.ed.gov/offices/OESE/DropoutPrev/dropoutpubs.html.
The article provides statistics on dropouts, discusses early risk factors and behaviors of dropouts, and proposes strategies for the prevention of dropouts.
Jacobson, L. (2000, November 29). Harvard project aims to strengthen teacher-parent bonds. Education Week. Retrieved June 17, 2002, from
http://www.edweek.com/ew/ewstory.cfm?slug=13family.h20&keywords=family%20involvement.
The article discusses the need for additional training for educators in order to facilitate and develop working relationships with parents and families of their students. Other topics include the development of the project FINE (Family Involvement Network of Educators). This project will be a resource for all teachers and teacher education programs to assist in the development of family involvement within the classroom and schools.
Jones, B., Valdez, G., Nowakowski, J., & Rasmussen, C. (1995). Designing Learning and Technology for Educational Reform. Oak Brook, IL: North Central Regional Educational Laboratory. Retrieved June 17, 2002, from http://www.ncrel.org/sdrs/engaged.htm).
Defines learner engagement and provides eight indicators of engagement and how to implement programs based on this theory.
Johnson, D. (2001). Performance pentagon: Five strategies to help all students make the grade. National Association of Secondary School Principals, 85, 40-55.
Kentucky Department of Education, Division of Career and Technical Education, (1998-99). “The Key to Learning” The Integration of Academics and Vocational Education, A Handbook of Activities and Units of Study
Loucks, H. E. & Waggoner, J. E. (1998). Keys to Reengaging Families in the Education of Young Adolescents. Columbus, OH: National Middle School Association
Massachutes Advocacy Center Web site: http://:www.volunteersolutions.org
Nadeau, A. (1997, Winter). Linguistic diversity and reform: Can practices be identified? Directions in Language and Education National Clearinghouse of Bilingual Education, 1, (10). Retrieved July 2, 2002, from http://www.ncbe.qwu.edu/ncbepubs/directions/10.htm
This article discusses the school reform and ethnic/ language diversity.
National Mental Health and Education Center. What can parents and teachers do if an adolescent begins to fail in school? [Brochure]. Bethesda, MD: National Association of School Psychologists. Retrieved June 17, 2002, from http://www.naspcenter.org/parents/parents_fail.htm.
The brochure discusses behaviors/factors of Middle School students’ potential at-risk of dropping out of school.
New times demand new ways of learning. In Jones, B., Valdez, G., Nowakowski, J., & Rasmussen, C. (1995). Designing Learning and Technology for Educational Reform. Oak Brook, IL: North Central Regional Educational Laboratory. Retrieved June 17, 2002, from http://www.ncrel.org/sdrs/edtalk/newtimes.htm#Teacher.
The article discusses many academic alternatives for the at-risk student. Topics include heterogeneous grouping and benefits, and the changing role of the educator within the classroom. Benefits to students and educator who are teamed together are also discussed.
North Central Regional Educational Laboratory. Critical issue: Providing effective schooling for students at-risk. Retrieved June 17, 2002, from http://www.ncrel.org/sdrs/areas/issues/students/atrisk/at600.htm.
This article defines several risk factors and behaviors for students that are at–risk and offers strategies for the early identification and prevention of dropout. It includes information on engagement through learner centered classrooms, heterogeneous grouping, parent involvement and interdisciplinary teacher teams.
Stringfield (1993). Specify the problems. Retrieved June 17, 2002, from North Central Regional Educational Laboratory Web site:
http://www.ncrel.org/sdrs/areas/issues/students/atrisk/at6lk63.htm.
This discusses issues that communities and schools need to address in order to assist students.
Payne, R. (2001). A framework for understanding poverty. Highlands, TX: Process, Inc. http://ahaprocess.com/AboutRubyPayne.html
Polk, R. (n.d.). Youth: Programs outcomes for youth reduction of risk behaviors in youth—academic risk. Retrieved June 17, 2002, from http://ag.arizona.edu/fcr/fs/nowg/ythrbacadrisk.html.
This article discusses different programs that have been designed to reach students in middle school and high school who would be considered at-risk for dropping out of school. Restructuring the ecology of the school as an approach to dropout prevention during school transitions is also a topic.
Project based learning. What is it? (n.d.). Retrieved on January 7, 2003, from the University of Kansas Web site: http://www.4teachers.org/projectbased/
Roderick, M. (1994). Grade retention and school dropout: investigating the association. American Educational Research Journal, 31, 729-759.
Rossi, R. & Montgomery, A. (Eds.) (1994). Studies of Education Reform. Educational reforms and students at risk: A review of the current state of the art (No. RR91-1172011). Washington, DC: US Department of Education, Office of Educational Research and Improvement. Retrieved June 17, 2002, from http://www.ed.gov/pubs/EdReformStudies/EdReforms/summ.html.
Defines and discusses strategies for schools to keep at risk students engaged.
Shumacher, D. (June, 1998). “The transition to middle school” Student achievement. Retrieved from Eric Clearinghouse Web site: http://ericeass.uncg.edu/virtuallib/achiev/1004.html
Smink, J. (2001). Alternatives to retention. National Association of Secondary School Principals, 85. Retrieved June 17, 2002, from http://www.nassp.org/news/bltn_altrntvs_to_retntn1201.html.
The focus includes retention, its effect upon students, and its effectiveness. It discusses the identification of the factors and situations that place students at risk for retention. Prevention of failure for these students and alternatives to traditional retention are discussed.
Schumacher, D. (1998, June). The transition to middle school. Retrieved on January 7, 2003 from the ERIC Clearinghouse on Elementary and Early Childhood Education Web site: http://ericcass.uncg.edu/virtuallib/achievement/1004.html
Southern Regional Education Board (n.d.). Senior Project Guide. Retrieved January 7, 2003 from the Web site: http://www.sreb.org/programs/hstw/publications/site-guides/SeniorProjectGuide.pdf
Southern Regional Education Board (n.d.). Using real-world projects to help students meet standards in education and the workplace. Retrieved January 7, 2003 from the Web site: http://www.sreb.org/programs/hstw/publications/site-guides/UsingRealWorldProjects.pdf
Tompkins, R. & Deloney, P. (1994). Rural students at-risk in Arkansas, Louisiana, New Mexico, Oklahoma, and Texas. (No. RP91002003). Austin, TX: Southeast Educational Development Laboratory. Retrieved June 17, 2002, from http://www.sedl.org/rural/atrisk/behaviors.html.
U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, Schools and Staffing Survey, 1990-91. Retrieved from http://nces.ed.gov/pubsold/COE95/45txt.html
Volman, B. (1996). You can't educate an empty chair: Increasing student attendance through parent involvement in regular classroom lessons.
Wells, A. S.(1999). Middle school education – The critical link in dropout prevention. ERIC/CUE Digest 56. Retrieved on January 7, 2003 from PENpages College of Agriculture, Penn State University Web site:
http://www.penpages.psu.edu/penpages_reference/28507/285072881.HTML
Copyright © 2003 Commonwealth of Kentucky.
All rights reserved.
Contact the Webmaster: ihdi-www@lsv.uky.edu